Table Sports

Why the Lowest-Price Commercial Gym Equipment Ends Up Costing You the Most

Why the Lowest-Price Commercial Gym Equipment Ends Up Costing You the Most

I bought 14 ellipticals. Three of them got used at peak times.

Three years ago, I signed off on the largest single equipment purchase our company had ever made — a full commercial cardio refresh for one of our three clubs. I was the procurement manager. My budget was roughly $180,000 across all three facilities. Over six years, I have logged every invoice from around 200 equipment orders in our cost tracking system, from single Cybex lat pulldown stations to pallets of treadmills.

And I still got it wrong.

Looking back, the problem didn't start with the price. I negotiated hard. I got exactly what I asked for. But what I asked for was the wrong thing, and I didn't know it until I pulled the utilization data six months later and saw that less than a quarter of our new ellipticals were seeing regular use. Meanwhile, two lonesome Concept 2 rowing machines in the corner had a line of members waiting for them every evening at 6 p.m.

The real problem starts before you call a sales rep

Most gym owners I talk to assume their equipment budget is a price negotiation problem. They ask me: “Where can I get the best deal on Cybex?” or “Is it cheaper to buy through the Cybex shop or through a dealer?” Or they compare a rowing machine vs elliptical on sticker price alone and go with whichever number is lower.

Look, I get it. My first instinct is always price, too. But after tracking about 200 orders over six years, I can tell you that price is almost never what makes an equipment purchase succeed or fail. The real failure happens before the PO is even drafted.

Here's what I mean. When I bought those 14 ellipticals, I was comparing quotes from three vendors on unit price, shipping, and lead time. I built a spreadsheet. I was thorough. But I never sat down and asked: What are our members actually going to do on this thing?

What I should have done is started with the workout plans our members follow. If your club offers templated training sessions — and most do, whether it's a custom program or something a member finds online — then your equipment mix needs to support the movements in those plans. If a member comes in following what I call a Cybex workout routine — the kind of circuit you can find templates for on the Cybex shop or any programming site — they need a standard high-pulldown, a seated row, a horizontal push, a vertical pull. If you buy the wrong type of machine, the member adapts by skipping it entirely.

Which brings me to an overlooked detail: most buyers asking about a lat pulldown muscles worked list assume it targets the “back” and leave it at that. The actual list is latissimus dorsi, teres major, biceps brachii, rhomboids, and posterior deltoids. That matters for procurement. If your members are focused on lat and lower-back strength, a standard, mid-quality selectorized lat pulldown is fine. You do not need the premium version with three grip widths and an adjustable converging angle — that's a 40-60% price Premium for features that, in a typical commercial setting, almost nobody uses.

The question everyone asks is “Who has the best price?” The question they should ask is “Which equipment matches the movements my members actually perform?”

What buying the wrong machine actually costs

Let me put real numbers on it, because that's the only way this lesson stuck for me.

Our 14 ellipticals ran about $28,000 total — roughly $2,000 per unit with delivery. Our average peak-hour utilization? About 23%. So we spent the equivalent of around $21,500 on equipment that sat empty during the times members were actually in the building.

Meanwhile, those two Concept 2 rowers served a constantly growing queue. We had bought them two years earlier on a whim. They cost less than $2,000 for the pair. They were, in practice, the most valuable cardio machines in the club — and we had only two of them.

Maintenance adds another layer. Commercial ellipticals typically run $150-$400 per unit annually in maintenance based on our own service records. We spent about $2,400 over 18 months on belt and bearing replacements across six units alone. The rowers? Almost zero. Fewer moving parts, lower failure rate. A concept 2 rowing machine, specifically, is designed to be field-serviceable, which keeps downtime and repair bills low.

But the cost that actually hurt wasn't maintenance. It was retention. I can't prove causality, but our internal data showed that peak-hour wait times on cardio correlated with a drop in renewal rates for our mid-tier monthly members. A member walks in at 6 p.m., sees eight empty ellipticals and two people waiting for a rower, and something clicks in their head: This place isn't set up for me. They don't come back.

Put another way: a $3,000 machine with zero utilization is a more expensive purchase than a $3,500 machine that runs at 70% capacity. The price tag on the invoice is just the opening number. The real cost is whatever you paid divided by how often it's actually used.

The procurement framework I use now

I don't start with price anymore. I start with usage.

Here's the process I now run before any commercial equipment order, large or small:

  1. Pull 90 days of utilization data. If you have equipment counters or connected apps, use those. If not, do a walk-through count at three peak times per week. You need relative rankings, not perfect precision. What has a queue? What collects dust?
  2. Map usage back to workout plans. If your club runs templated programs — or if you stock any branded equipment like Cybex, whose shop publishes workout routines — list the movements required. Then compare to what you own. Mark gaps and overlaps.
  3. Segment cardio by member type. Rowing machine vs elliptical isn't a blanket answer. It depends entirely on who is using it and when. Younger, performance-focused members tend to gravitate toward the Concept 2 rowing machine. Older, low-impact, steady-state members prefer the elliptical. Don't let price decide which one you stock — let the demographics of your actual membership decide.
  4. Build a first-year total cost estimate. Unit price, installation, year-one maintenance, and downtime risk. Add a line for “expected utilization.” I can't stress that last one enough — it changes the math completely.
  5. Compare brands on fit, not on price. Whether you're looking at Cybex, Concept 2, or another manufacturer, the brand name matters less than whether the specific piece fits your members' actual movement patterns. If two options are within 10% on total cost, pick the one that matches your workout plans more closely. The cheaper one will feel expensive the first time nobody uses it.

My experience here is based on roughly 200 mid-range commercial orders across three facilities. If you're building a luxury studio or a budget-friendly 24-hour gym, your calculus might look different. But one principle I haven't seen fail yet: utilization is the only number that really matters. The price tag is just decoration.

Discuss this topic with Stiga
Alina Petrescu

Alina Petrescu

Alina Petrescu is a commercial cardio-equipment analyst specializing in treadmills, ellipticals, exercise bikes, rowers, stair climbers, and connected training consoles. She references ISO 20957-6 and ISO 20957-9 while examining speed and incline accuracy, braking, belt tracking, stride geometry, resistance range, power draw, user weight, duty cycle, noise, and service intervals. Her analysis helps health clubs, hotels, universities, and corporate gyms match performance, accessibility, throughput, energy use, connectivity, and maintenance demands to high-traffic operating plans.

Previous: Cybex vs. Budget Commercial Equipment: An Honest Comparison From a Gym Buyer Next: We Ordered 12 'Best' Bowling Balls. Seven Sat for Four Months.